(WCTW) Let Them

If the market will only care when an outright oil shortage shows up, then so be it.

Price drives narrative. At least that’s what’s happened to the energy community in the past week or so. The consecutive successive attempts by Axios and the Trump administration’s daily attempts at jawboning oil prices have effectively changed the specialists’ minds.

“Perhaps we aren’t going to have an oil shortage... after all?”

The amount of myopicness in the oil market today is at an all-time high. Barrel counters have seemingly forgotten the simple fact that there are storage facilities that are unobservable by satellite data: products and underground storage.

So instead of coming to the logical conclusion that the 12 million b/d of production shut-in is known, and the inventory draws in unknown storage tanks are unknown, they have seemingly flipped the facts around.

I suppose these are crazy times, and it goes to show just how few people can have lucid thoughts these days. Only time will tell who is eventually right.

Shortages

We are now so far past the point of no return that there is no point of returning back to the status quo. I’ve been getting asked questions like, “What happens if the Strait of Hormuz reopens today?” But these questions fail to answer one important question:

Who will control the Strait of Hormuz?

This single event will have an immense impact on the future trajectory of the oil market. As I have said since the beginning of the Iran conflict, the Strait of Hormuz card cannot be played again. Either Iran controls it, or the regime is toppled. There is no middle ground. This is all or nothing.

This simple distinction is what sets my understanding of the conflict apart from others. The consensus still believes there will be a framework to allow a gradual reopening or for Iran to charge a toll. No, these are all nonstarters. Either they get control, or they don’t; there’s no other way around it.

So it’s interesting to see sell-side analysts like JPM talk about how the Strait of Hormuz will reopen by June because global oil inventories are headed for a tank bottom, as if this scenario somehow resolves the geopolitical conflicts.

Wishful thinking much?

But again, it is what it is. If they are going to think like that, let them. I’m not interested in changing people’s minds at this point. I’m here to make money, and I’ve already put my money where my mouth is.

This brings me to the point I want to discuss. Perhaps the market will only care about outright shortages at this point before pricing in demand destruction. Maybe the market is inefficient, and we just have to force shortages down its throat before it inflects.

So what does the timing look like?